top of page

How Nonprofits Should Measure Impact and ROI Before Submitting Grant Proposals

When applying for grants, demonstrating a clear, measurable impact and a strong Return on Investment (ROI) can make all the difference. While nonprofits often wait to assess impact after funding is secured, evaluating impact potential before  submitting a grant proposal can significantly strengthen your application. By showing funders a data-backed projection of the impact their dollars will make, you set your organization apart as results-driven and transparent. Here’s how nonprofits can measure and communicate impact and ROI effectively before they submit a proposal. 1. Define Clear Impact Objectives Aligned with the Funder’s Goals Funders want to see that your program’s goals align closely with their mission. Define objectives that connect your mission with measurable impact areas—whether it’s the number of people served, improvements in skills or health, or broader community benefits. When setting these objectives, consider the funder’s specific priorities. Craft your goals to reflect the outcomes they value most, demonstrating that you understand their impact expectations.
2. Develop Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) KPIs provide a framework for measuring progress toward your objectives. For each program or project, establish KPIs that will show funders exactly how you plan to track success. Use a mix of quantitative and qualitative KPIs, such as the number of beneficiaries, program completion rates, or participant satisfaction scores. Highlight these KPIs in your proposal to give funders a clear, structured picture of how impact will be measured.
3. Analyze Cost-Effectiveness and Projected ROI Demonstrating cost-effectiveness and ROI shows funders that their resources will be used responsibly. Calculate anticipated expenses and projected outcomes to create a “cost per outcome” metric (e.g., cost per individual served). Consider preparing a “break-even analysis” to show when you expect the program to yield measurable results in relation to costs. Highlight these metrics in your proposal to build funder confidence in your financial stewardship.
4. Present Impact Projections with Outcomes and Outputs Funders are looking for programs that will create meaningful change, not just deliver services. To showcase this, present both the outputs  (e.g., "200 students trained") and outcomes  (e.g., “80% of participants secure employment within 6 months”). Outline the short- and long-term impact in your proposal, providing funders with a balanced view of what their support will accomplish immediately and over time. This distinction shows you’re not only tracking reach but are also focused on meaningful, sustainable change.
5. Estimate Community Impact and Broader Ripple Effects Many programs have broader benefits that extend beyond direct participants. Estimating these “ripple effects” can add significant value to your proposal. For example, a program that helps local youth find employment may reduce local unemployment and boost community economic health. Use both qualitative and quantitative methods, such as local surveys, community feedback, or secondary research, to support these broader impact projections. Funders appreciate knowing their grant will create wider-reaching benefits.
6. Prepare Benchmarks and Comparisons To make your case stronger, compare your anticipated impact with industry benchmarks or similar programs. If you expect to achieve outcomes that are above average in cost-effectiveness or participant success rates, this is highly appealing to funders. Include any relevant statistics or studies that validate your projections. By using benchmarks, you show that your proposal isn’t just ambitious but also realistic, based on proven standards.
7. Calculate Social Return on Investment (SROI) Social Return on Investment (SROI) measures the financial value of social impact. While complex, SROI projections demonstrate the long-term, tangible benefits of a program to funders in monetary terms. To calculate SROI, estimate the financial value of projected outcomes. For example, if your program helps individuals secure employment, estimate the long-term economic benefits, such as increased lifetime earnings. Include these projections in your proposal to provide funders with a concrete picture of their “return.”
8. Evaluate Your Organization’s Grant Readiness Funders want to partner with organizations that are capable and prepared. Assess your current readiness for this specific grant and communicate any systems you have in place for tracking outcomes, managing funds, and reporting. Highlight existing processes, like grant management software, staff expertise, or internal evaluation frameworks. By showing that you’re operationally ready, funders can be confident that their grant will be managed responsibly and effectively.
9. Emphasize Your Capacity for Long-Term Impact Many funders look for programs that will deliver lasting benefits. Show that your organization is committed to sustained impact by presenting a plan for ongoing evaluation, follow-up, or phased scaling of the program. Outline your capacity to continue delivering results and, if relevant, your intention to secure additional resources for the program’s longevity. This demonstrates that your organization is capable of creating a lasting difference.
Putting It All Together: Creating a Strong Proposal Framework To maximize your grant proposal’s appeal, build a framework that showcases both impact potential and fiscal responsibility. Begin with clear objectives, present a structured plan for tracking KPIs, and outline projected outcomes and community benefits. Organize your impact projections using visuals like charts, tables, or infographics to make data easy to digest. Include concise narrative explanations that clarify assumptions and make the case for why these projections are achievable.
Conclusion: Setting Up for Success Before Submitting Measuring impact and ROI before submitting a grant proposal allows your nonprofit to approach funders with clear, data-backed projections that demonstrate value and readiness. By thoughtfully preparing and presenting anticipated outcomes, your nonprofit not only sets itself apart but also fosters funder trust and enthusiasm. Taking this proactive approach shows that your organization is focused on transparency, accountability, and maximizing the impact of each grant dollar, paving the way for a successful partnership and future funding opportunities.

How Nonprofits Should Measure Impact and ROI Before Submitting Grant Proposals
bottom of page